≡ Menu

The ugly truth about blog commenting

If you’ve ever operated or administered a blog, you can spot them from a mile away.

The comment appears in your moderation queue days or weeks or even months after the post in question was published. On the surface, it seems like the comment was written a by a real person and is really intended to chime in on the post in question, but upon further analysis, it’s fairly clear that the verbiage being used is actually very generic and intended to fit into a very broad and general context (the one’s I get most often are derivatives of “this is great SEO advice!”). Last but not least, the comment signature is jam packed with juicy keywords like “SEO Alaska” or “black belt buckles” or some other very obvious target keyword in someone’s SEO marketing program.

And then you have the completely overt, machine-generated garbage that doesn’t even attempt to seem human and consists of a sloppy menagerie of links and is clearly aimed at exploiting blogs that don’t have comment moderation enabled.

Why do these folks go through the trouble to secure some measly blog comment links and anchor text, you ask?

Simply put, because it works.

As those of you that regularly read this blog know, inbound links and anchor text are still the foundation of Google’s natural search algorithm. Therefore, securing links and anchor text is still a key piece of the SEO puzzle, and one of the easiest ways to secure keyword-rich anchor text (other than buying links) is to put it in the comment sections of do-follow blogs.

The marketplace has become so mature that there are even blog commenting software packages available to help streamline, manage, and even semi-automate the process of finding relevant blogs that allow for do follow commenting (disclosure: this is an affiliate link, I’ve used this thing, and it’s pretty darn good).

Now would I advocate blog commenting as the cornerstone of a White Hat SEO program? Absolutely not. But can it be a small, experimental portion of your overall strategy? Sure, why not. Especially, if the focus is on identifying relevant blogs and leaving genuine, legitimate comments that actually add value to the blog community.

When leveraged in this manner, it’s actually a very legitimate hybrid of social media and SEO that can help build credibility and relationships as well as manifesting the occasional keyword-rich anchor text link.

P.S. Don’t bother trying to sneak in unnatural anchor text into this blog via the comments section. Homey don’t play that (but do feel free to chime in!).

Comments on this entry are closed.

  • Victor

    Hi . Nice post about blog commenting .

  • Anonymous

    Thanks for the comment and the compliment, Victor!

  • http://www.paleobreafast.org Joshua

    I use comments for multiple SEO purposes and to build connection for the future. To be an effecient blog reader I use Google reader and don’t always get a chance to read all of the blog post I want until weeks later.

    I found that I often get links showing in my webmaster tools from nofollowed comments.

    Sometimes I wonder how many web-masters know what is going on with comment spam?

    PS no link on this comment ;)

    • Anonymous

      Thanks for the comment, Joshua! And no sweat on the blog links : )

  • Anonymous

    I know this post is not fresh pro today´s point of view, but commenting can still be very atractive to get a direct traffic.

  • colgan smith

    thank for shearing for info.

    http://www.ithinksoluciones.com.mx/

  • Anonymous

    Awesome post forward by your. I like it your blog…

  • http://twitter.com/legal_ayuda Abogados Miami.

    Valuable information is often unknown, but it is important to keep up.

  • Anonymous

    I think the point most of the SEO aspirants miss. Google best practices recommend to participate POSITIVELY in and around your niche by way of blogs and forums. There is no mention about do follow or the no follow stuff and also about how you will anchor when commenitng on blogs.

    They say that you participate and if your post creates interest people will follow back to your website and this is what Google loves to see.

    • http://www.seoservicesplus.ca SEO Services Company

      Well said. But in a doggy eat doggy world, we all try to stiff out the competition as you have with your user name above that leads straight to your site. So let’s give it a go. No not worth it. This is an excellent post but i would argue, if Google’s algorithmic flow deems blog comments worthy, then why not? While your trying to be part of the community, someone else is blasting comments here and there surpassing the number of links you have. If the difference in being number 1 is in links, then this strategy is worthy of its calling. It’s a double-fold, some blogs would probably not even receive any visitors without commenting option. Thanks.

    • http://www.geckoandfly.com/ Ngan Tengyuen

      I wonder how do they determine what is positive or negative?

  • Eka Liscano

    This article provides a light in which we can observe reality. This is very nice and provide in-depth information. thank you for this nice article.

  • Diga Lign

    This post is fantastic! This is most complete explanation of these new capabilities that I’ve seen yet. Thank you for this very timely explanation.
    visit our site : http://www.digalign.com/

  • perficio soft

    Nice blog .Happy to discover this site .We have a sour by bellow to learn something new http://www.perficiosoft.com/

  • Diga Lign

    Thanks for putting this up. It looks like an up and coming blog. And definitely a good place for commenting!

    visit our site : http://www.digalign.com/

  • Pamela Philips

    Hi, all are very crucial information which is more bloggers relate to this. What a great explanation you shared. Devastating post.

    http://backlinkmonopoly.com/

  • john

    Protocol command set download ebook

    http://cleanfiles.net/?gcNJ3dk

    or

    http://cleanfiles.net/?6Y2N5sM

  • http://www.omnitecindia.com/ Parking Management

    Do follow blogs are very important for SEO,And good information about this blog, and posted lot of do follow links, thanks for sharing here with us.

    parking management

    parking guidance

    parking counting

  • Zenia

    I like to do it for my service WATER DAMAGE REPAIR TAMPA
    waterdamagerestorationtampa.org

  • Jeselle Arce

    Most of the people enter into the blogging industry with only one goal and that is to make as much money as possible. While it may seem really easy to make money in blogging world, from a distance, but once you will enter into this industry, you will realize all those hardships through which a blogger has to go through to become successful. Blogging is not a bed of roses and this is something that you should always keep in your mind. But I want to recommend a tool, this is the Colibri Tool since I find it, it is worthy enough to be used by SEO specialists.